Spoiled Discussion

[special]

bah!

I think town would have been better served to look elsewhere.

Yes, their stories didn't match.

If Natlaw was honest, then Sister was Scum.

If Sister was honest, then neither of them were scum!

[special]

It's 3-3-1, right?

If I'd accepted recruitment, I could possibly have won already (assuming I didn't get lynched)

[drainbead]

So who killed me? Scum or Natlaw?

[Frank]

Feb 8, 2010 14:13:24 GMT -5 drainbead said:

So who killed me? Scum or Natlaw?

Scum killed you. Their logic is impenetrable to me. I don't know why they leave tomscud alive and alive and alive to reduce the hiding pool by one every Day, but they do.

Natlaw still has his pumpkin bomb tucked away for use later in the game. If he survives toDay, he has a real chance of winning the game (but he should have self-protected last Night; that would have put him really close).

But I may hold the embarassing distinction of being the first-ever mod to design a true broken game - ie, one that cannot be won. The Scum have basically resolved to pile on natlaw toDay, and once all three do that then unless they move a vote, it will be impossible for the Town to lynch anyone else (barring a miracle return by PCM). They could publicly announce that they are the three Scum and they are voting for Natlaw and Town can do nothing about it.

But Town would be total fools to vote for Natlaw, because they know they are at LoL and they know (if they think about it a bit) that if they lynch him, they lose the game. Eventually they will twig to what's going on, and mhaye/tomscud will vote for, say, nphase, with Natlaw following suit. What then? In the absence of PCM, and the way the game is currently designed, the result would be a stalemate that would last until eternity.

Even if I randomly broke the stalemate, that would be the same as randomly determining the winner of the game, more or less.

I suck.

[drainbead]

The reason I asked in the non-spoiled thread who Bill subbed for was because I couldn't remember if he was Scum (I thought he was), but the vote for Natlaw was inexplicable to me. The only people who want Natlaw dead toDay are Scum, as you mentioned above. If I were still in the game, that vote would have earned an immediate vote from me.

I can't believe Scum killed me. I could see it from Natlaw, but not from them. I figured that Natlaw mistakenly thought I was Scum and went for it. Scum plus Natlaw could have mislynched me the next Day. I was certain that Natlaw would be the dead one in the morning.

[special]

OK, Bill has exposed himself as Scum...

red's claim was great.

His 'post from story' was weak. I think he's exposed now.

[drainbead]

Yeah, he should have said he took on a protective role. There's no way that can be independently verified, and better, it's what Town needs more than anything right now. They don't need a Cop--they need someone to avoid NKs.

[drainbead]

If the Scum are smart, they all vote PCM right now.